Is granulated sugar the same as white sugar

Natural cane sugar is made from sugar cane, while conventional white granulated sugar may be made from either cane or sugar beets. Since both plants produce molecules of sucrose that are identical, this is not a significant distinction. Also, the “natural” tag is a bit of an oversell: Natural cane sugar is only slightly less processed than regular white sugar. That said, it retains a bit of a blond color.

How the Sugars Taste Plain

Some tasters found that cane sugar had slightly more depth of flavor compared with regular granulated sugar when they tasted both plain, but overall the sugars tasted very similar.

How Cane Sugar Behaves in Recipes

With such slight differences in the sugars, we weren’t surprised that sugar cookies made with cane sugar had a slightly deeper color but otherwise were no different from the batch made with conventional granulated sugar.

We had more of an issue with simple syrup. The natural cane sugar produced a liquid with a caramel tint rather than the traditional colorless syrup. While a brown syrup would be fine in iced tea, it might discolor lemonade or a pale cocktail (like a Black Tea–Port Milk Punch).

We also found natural sugar to be problematic in caramel sauce. The syrup in the pan was brown from the start, which made it hard to detect color changes. Furthermore, the impurities in the natural cane sugar caused foaming (to varying degrees depending on the brand), in one case making it impossible to get an accurate temperature reading.

The takeaway

We found that cane sugar is acceptable in some applications, such as sugar cookies, but it should be avoided in recipes in which its slightly darker color gives the food a brown tint.

Is granulated sugar the same as white sugar

07 Aug 2019 - Anneka Manning

I often get asked about the difference between granulated sugar and caster sugar and which is best used for when baking… So here’s the low-down:

The main difference between granulated (also know as white table sugar) and caster (also know as super-fine in North America) sugar is the size of the grain.

Granulated is larger and more coarse (I once read that granulated is about 0.5mm in diameter while caster is about 0.35mm in diameter, although I’m not really sure who would measure them!). Because of this caster sugar is generally the most versatile and preferred of the two when baking – its small granules mixes more easily and dissolve more readily when combined with other ingredients giving biscuits, cakes, pastries etc. a more even, less coarse texture.

You may have noticed if you have made a cake with granulated sugar that it sometimes can have a ‘speckled’ appearance – this is the undissolved sugar in the batter. Caster sugar is also best to use when making meringues and pavlova because of its ability to dissolve more quickly. Granulated sugar however is great when making toffee (it is less likely to crystalize), in general cooking and in baking when your want a slightly coarser texture (for example, I often make a traditional Scottish shortbread that has a better, more suitable texture when made with granulated sugar). My advise is to use whichever sugar is specified in the recipe and if you don’t have caster sugar in your cupboard you can always make it by processing granulated sugar in a food processor using the pulse button until finely ground.

Your cakes and biscuits will have a slightly finer texture when using caster sugar while if you use white sugar, your cakes will have a slightly coarser texture and your biscuits more crunch. It’s also good to note that icing sugar is just a finer version of caster sugar, with the crystals being ground to a fine powder.

Is granulated sugar the same as white sugar
Granulated sugar pressed into sugar cubes.

Granulated sugar, also sometimes known as “refined,” “table,” or “white” sugar, is beet or cane sugar which has been processed, allowed to crystallize, and then dried so that the crystals do not clump together. Many people think of granulated sugar when they hear the word “sugar,” and this variety is readily available in most markets and food shops around the world. It is very commonly used in cooking and baking, and recipes that call for sugar without specifying the type usually mean granulated.

Common Uses of Granulated Sugar

Is granulated sugar the same as white sugar
Sugar beets are a source of sugar.

This sort of highly processed sugar is one of the most popular baking ingredients in the world. It is a simple carbohydrate that dissolves well, melts easily, and blends into a wide variety of other ingredients. It is frequently used in any number of baked goods, and is also popular in small amounts to balance savory sauces and soups. It has a subtle flavor that usually complements other tastes rather than competing with them, which makes it a very easy way to add sweetness without disrupting a dish or confection’s main taste profile. People also use it to sweeten drinks, particularly coffee and tea, and many manufacturers sell it in pre-measured single-serving packets or pressed into small sugar cubes for this purpose.

Is granulated sugar the same as white sugar
Granulated sugar in a bowl.

Most “table” or standard granulated sugar has a fine, powdery consistency, but it is sometimes possible to find even more refined varieties. Caster and the so-called “superfine” sugar are variations that are distinguished more by the size of the crystals than anything about the way they have been processed or refined, and are prized in many more delicate desserts and baked foods like souffles that need to be light and airy.

Where Granulated Sugar Comes From

Is granulated sugar the same as white sugar
Granulated sugar is often used in baking.

Sugar is a naturally-occurring compound that can be found in most plant and animal cells. Most fruits, for instance, have very high sugar concentrations, which is one of the reasons that they taste so sweet. People since ancient times have looked for ways of extracting this sweetness so that it can be used on its own, a process known as “refinement,” and granulated sugar is one of the most popular results.

Refinement typically works best when there are very high concentrations of sugar to begin with. Manufacturers usually choose to work with either sugar beets or cane, two plants that contain large stores of natural sugars. Refining from other fruits, like apples or peaches, can be very time consuming and also tends to leave a lot of waste.

Granulated Sugar Refining Process

Making granulated sugar is a multi-step process. Refiners begin by isolating the sugar crystals in the beet or cane, usually through diffusion. During diffusion, the sugar source is soaked in water, ground or pulverized to expose its inner cells, then left to evaporate, often over mesh sieves or fine cloth where the crystals can be collected. At this stage, the crystals are usually light brown or tan in color.

Raw sugar isn’t quite the same as granulated sugar, though; in most cases, a lot more processing is required to get from one point to the next. First comes “affination,” where refiners break the crystals down with water and often some sort of phosphorous compound. Affination usually results in a thick sugary syrup that manufacturers have to heat and then quickly cool in order to get the sugar to re-crystallize. They sometimes use chemical agents to help speed things up. The result is usually two-fold: fine white granules and rich, dark syrup. Refiners typically sell one as granulated sugar and the other as molasses.

Is Cane Sugar the Same as Granulated Sugar?

Cane sugar is similar to granulated sugar, but cane sugar is made only out of sugar cane, not sugar beets. Cane sugar is also less processed than other types of sugars. Cane sugar has a golden hue to it, whereas granulated sugar is white. The color of cane sugar comes from molasses that remains in the crystals after the refining process. Cane sugar crystals are also slightly larger compared to granulated sugar. Despite these differences, cane sugar usually makes a nice substitute for granulated sugar in certain recipes.

Storage Tips and Shelf Life

Refinement helps the sugar resist clumping in part because it dries the crystals out so much. People who live in warm climates or whose sugar is exposed to high humidity may still experience clumping, though; this is harmless, but can make precise measuring more difficult and can also impact how evenly sugar dissolves or incorporates into different batters or broths. People can often break up clumps with their fingers or the backside of a spoon, though stubborn lumps may need the help of a food processor or blender. Keeping the crystals in an airtight container in a cool, dry place is one of the best ways to prevent clumps in the first place.

Sugar rarely spoils, and will stay fresh for a year or more. Past this point, the granules don’t really become harmful, but they may begin to lose their taste or begin to take on the flavors of their storage environment. Most food experts recommend using table sugar within a few months of purchase for the best results.

Substitutions for Granulated Sugar

Granulated versions of sugar are widely available in most places, though there are times when people may want to substitute other, less processed alternatives, either as a way of reducing sugar intake or as a means of making a more healthful selection. So-called “raw” sugar is a popular alternative in many markets. Raw sugar is usually collected before affination, which means that its crystals are slightly larger and often appear somewhat tan in color. It tends to taste somewhat sweeter and it usually dissolves more slowly than granulated versions, which means that people can use less.

People looking to avoid sugar entirely may also look to natural substances like honey, agave, and stevia, and there are usually a number of chemical sweeteners available, too. Bakers usually need to be somewhat careful of using substitutions in recipes, however; different substances react differently when blended and heated. Using the chemical sweetener aspartame in baked goods doesn’t usually work out, for instance, and using the honey — which is wet and sticky — can often change the overall texture of the final product that was intended to have been made with sugar. It’s usually a good idea for cooks to spend a little bit of time experimenting before replacing white sugar entirely.

Can I Substitute Brown Sugar for Granulated Sugar?

People are often tempted to equate white sugar with brown sugar, but the two are quite different, and substituting one for the other rarely ends well. In many cases, brown sugar is little more than granulated white sugar to which manufacturers have added molasses. The taste is a lot different as a result, and so is the density. A cake made with brown sugar when the recipe called for white, for instance, will often turn out to be very heavy, and may not rise properly.

Can I Substitute Powdered Sugar for Granulated Sugar?

Typically, powdered sugar is not a suitable substitute for granulated sugar. Powdered sugar goes by several different names including confectioner’s sugar or icing sugar. Powdered sugar is granulated sugar that has been refined to a powder and mixed with cornstarch. Because of powdered sugar’s fine texture and the presence of cornstarch in powdered sugar, it can react unpredictably when cooked. It does not make a suitable substitute for granulated sugar in most cases.

How to Make Glaze with Granulated Sugar

Sugar glazes are used to top cakes, muffins, and loaves of sweetbread. Sugar glaze is usually a clear glaze that adds a little something extra to desserts and sweetbreads. If you’re interested in using granulated sugar to make a glaze, it is possible. First, you will need to decide if you want to make a basic glaze or a glaze flavored with lemon, rosemary, or any other of your favorite flavors. To make a basic glaze, you will need to combine one part sugar with two parts water or milk.

Combine the sugar and water or milk over low heat and continually stir. The sugar crystals will eventually break down to form a smooth glaze. If you would rather add a little flavor, you can add a splash of vanilla extract, banana or coconut extract, or even melted butter. Whatever your flavor preferences, start out with a small bit of extract first and then adjust to your tastes. The glaze will cool quickly so it’s best to add it to your desserts soon after the crystals have broken down. Handle sugar glaze with extreme care.

Granulated Sugar Health Information

Granulated sugar is what is known as a simple carbohydrate, which basically means that it is a “quick energy” source that the body converts to glucose relatively soon after digestion. Most health experts advise people to maintain a balance between simple carbs and more complex high-protein foods that take longer to break down. When the body takes in more sugar than it needs, it often stores the excess in fat cells.

Another possible downside to granulated or refined sugar is its lack of nutrients. Most foods that are highly processed contain very little in the way of vitamins and minerals, and sugar is no exception. It is often very high in calories without providing much nutritive value. Most medical professionals recommend consuming sugar in any form “sparingly,” which means that ideally it should be more of a rare treat than a dietary staple. Excessive sugar intake has been linked to health problems like type-2 diabetes and obesity.

Is Granulated Sugar Vegan?

While granulated sugar comes from sugar beets or sugar cane, the refining process for granulated sugar uses bone char to achieve the white color. Because of the use of bone char, most refined sugars are not vegan-friendly. Some sugar manufacturers are certified vegan, but you will need to check the company’s website or PETA’s website to be sure. To be safe, you can always sweeten your foods with maple syrup or agave nectar instead.

Whether you’re using sweetener in a cake recipe or your coffee, there are many varieties of sweeteners. While granulated sugar is possibly the most widely known form of sugar, it is only one option of many.

Can I use white sugar instead of granulated?

White sugar milled into smaller crystals. It's also called superfine sugar. It dissolves more easily, making it perfect for recipes like custard from scratch, meringues and cakes. In most recipes you can substitute granulated sugar for caster sugar and vice versa.

Can you replace granulated sugar with sugar?

Brown sugar is the simplest substitute for granulated sugar. You can use light or dark brown sugar as a 1:1 substitute. It makes for darker, denser baked goods with a more caramel or molasses flavor, which is wonderful for classic chocolate chip cookies, but less desirable for delicate cakes.

What type of sugar is granulated sugar?

Granulated sugar is a type of sugar most people would be familiar with. Also known as refined, white or table sugar, this type is what's most commonly used in baking and cooking recipes. Granulated sugar comes from the sugar cane plant and is 100% sucrose. For more information about table sugar, see our article '.

What is the difference between fine sugar and granulated sugar?

Somewhere between granulated and powdered is superfine sugar (sometimes called caster sugar). It has smaller granules than regular white sugar, but isn't quite ground into fine powder. This sugar variety dissolves quickly making it perfect for meringues (you can get more meringue tips here).